Methodology Critique Assignment (Article Critique Sample)
Read the article posted in the “Methodology Critique Assignment” section of Blackboard, answer the critique questions. the article was
Lin, S., Zhou, J., Yang, L., & Chen, Y. (2013). Pain, fatigue, disturbed sleep and distress comprised a symptom cluster that related to quality of life and functional status of lung cancer surgery patients. Journal of Clinical Nursing, 22(9-10), 1281-1290.
Number of sources: 6
this sample demonstrates my ability to criticize an article
Research Article Critique
Research Article Critique
A research article is a representation of the results found after conducting a particular research. It should be well presented from the article title to the presentation of the results. For a medical research article, the abstract needs to be well structured. The analysis of results should be clear, concise, and to the point. The methodology should also be well explained and the results well presented in graphs and tables (Kothari, 2004). This paper seeks to examine whether the research article “Pain, Fatigue, Disturbed Sleep And Distress Comprised A Symptom Cluster That Related To Quality Of Life And Functional Status Of Lung Cancer Surgery Patients” (Lin, Zhou, Yang, & Chen, 2013, p. 1281), is a good representation of the study and its results.
The title of the article, which is “Pain, fatigue, disturbed sleep and distress comprised a symptom cluster that related to quality of life and functional status of lung cancer surgery patients” (Lin, Zhou, Yang, & Chen, 2013, p. 1281), accurately, describes the article. It is well defined in terms of what was being researched on and the major results. It is also very clear and easy to understand. Again, the language used is very simple with no overutilization of technical terms. From this title, it is easy to know the research problem and the results found.
Its abstract effectively represents the entire article since it is well structured. It is divided into a series of headings, including aims and objectives, background, design, methods, results, conclusion, and relevance to clinical practice. It includes a summary of all the topics in the article. From the abstract, one can deduce everything in the article. The summaries have the relevant key words including symptom cluster, lung cancer, functional status, and quality of life, with no repetition of words or phrases. Structured abstracts are used in medical and clinical literature. This article is a medical literature, making the use of a structured abstract the most appropriate thing to do.
The introduction of this article shows clearly its intended purpose, which is to “explore the common symptom cluster in lung cancer patients with surgical treatment and to evaluate the relationships between symptom cluster and patients’ disease outcomes, including functional status and quality of life” (Lin, Zhou, Yang, & Chen, 2013, p. 1281). It introduces the prevailing problem that in 2010, lung cancer contributed to most of the male deaths and was second to breast cancer in women; it goes ahead to explain why there is need to research on the problem to improve the quality of life of such patients. The purpose of the article comes out very clearly and is presented in simple language, making it easily comprehensible.
The research problem appears as the first thing in the introduction (Kothari, 2004). It brings out the hypothesis that lung cancer is the most common male disease and in women, it has the second highest death rates. This hypothesis itself introduces the need for the research. The research problem is very essential in the construction of research objectives, methodology, budget, and work plan (McGaghie, Bordage, & Shea, 2001). In this article, the problem statement has been properly introduced as the first thing in the introduction.
Purpose of the Study
In this article, the purpose of the study has been explained through the aims and objectives. It Cleary explains the aims and objectives, which are “To explore the common symptom cluster in lung cancer patients with surgical treatment and to evaluate the relationships between symptom cluster and patients’ disease outcomes, including functional status and quality of life” (Lin, Zhou, Yang, & Chen, 2013, p.1281). This is a trouble-free and lucid rationalization of the purpose of conducting the research.
The research question is not well defined on its own in this article. The implicit research question should be: what are the common symptom clusters in lung cancer patients with surgical treatment? The research problem serves as the basis for the relationship between the different elements involved in a research. The goal of a research is the main objective of the study. The goal details what the research study intends to do to address the problem. The research goal, which in this case was to explore the common symptom cluster in lung cancer patients with surgical treatment, should be operationalized by the research question. The research question is meant to narrow the purpose in to the specific questions to be addressed in the study. The research question is included in the purpose of the study and does not have to be well defined on its own. It is upon the reader to understand the relationships between the research purpose and research question and understand what the research question is.
In this article, the theoretical framework is not readily available. A theoretical framework consists of concepts and their definitions and existing theories that are used for a particular study. It connects the researcher to existing knowledge relevant to the study. Though the theoretical framework in this article is not readily available, a review of the article literature reveals that the theoretical framework is described. The background section of the article reveals existing knowledge about symptoms of cancer and the relationship between these symptoms in relation to the disease. Different theories have been included in this section, such as “fatigue affected m...
- Methodology Critique AssignmentDescription: A research article is a representation of the results found after conducting a particular research. It should be well presented from the article title to the presentation of the results....6 pages/≈1650 words| 8 Sources | APA | Life Sciences | Article Critique |