Sign In
Not register? Register Now!
You are here: HomeEssayLaw
Pages:
3 pages/≈825 words
Sources:
2 Sources
Level:
APA
Subject:
Law
Type:
Essay
Language:
English (U.S.)
Document:
MS Word
Date:
Total cost:
$ 12.96
Topic:

Role and Functions of Law (Essay Sample)

Instructions:
CASE 2.1 Cipollone vs. Liggett Group, Inc., et al., 505 U.S. 504 (1992) FACT SUMMARY Cipollone brought suit against Liggett for violation of several New Jersey consumer protection statutes alleging that Liggett (and other cigarette manufacturers) were liable for his mother's death because they engaged in a course of conduct including false advertising, fraudulently misrepresenting the hazards of smoking, and conspiracy to deprive the public of medical and scientific information about smoking. Liggett urged the court to dismiss the state law claims contending that the claims related to the manufacturer's advertising and promotional activities were preempted by two federal laws: (1) the Federal Cigarette Labeling and Advertising Act of 1965, and (2) the Public Health Cigarette Smoking Act of 1969. SYNOPSIS OF DECISION AND OPINION The U.S. Supreme Court ruled against Cipollone, holding that his claims relying on state law were preempted by federal law. The Court cited both the text of the statute and the legislative history in concluding that Congress's intent in enactment of the laws was to preempt state laws regulating the advertising and promotion of tobacco products. Because Congress chose specifically to regulate a certain type of advertising tobacco), federal law is supreme to any state law that attempts to regulate that same category of advertising. WORDS OF THE COURT: Preemption “Article VI of the Constitution provides that the laws of the United States shall be the supreme Law of the Land. Thus, [. . .] it has been settled that state law that conflicts with federal law is ‘without effect.' [. . .] Accordingly, ‘the purpose of congress is the ultimate touchstone' of pre-emption analysis. Congress's intent may be ‘explicitly stated in the statute's language or implicitly contained in its structure and purpose.' In the absence of an express congressional command, state law is preempted if that law actually conflicts with federal law, [. . .], or if federal law so thoroughly occupies a legislative field ‘as to make reasonable the inference that Congress left no room for the States to supplement it.' [. . .] [Cipollone's] claims are preempted to the extent that they rely on a state-law ‘requirement or prohibition . . . with respect to . . . advertising or promotion.' ” Case Questions 1. Given the Supreme Court's language and the result of this case, is Congress's preemption power broad or narrow? Explain your answer. 2. Does the Supreme Court's ruling bar all residents of New Jersey, or any other state, from bringing suit against a tobacco company for false advertising or promotion? Why or why not? 3. Why would Congress want to preempt state law regarding the advertising and promotion of tobacco products? Do you agree with their decision to do so? Why or why not? source..
Content:
Functions and Role of Law in Business and Society Name Institution Functions and Role of Law in Business and Society Law is crucial for the maintenance of order in all spheres of life. Humanity must be manned and controlled for coexistence and protection from exploitation, particularly where interacting parties have different goals and objectives. The society and its constituents would be chaotic without law because law is the only tool for controlling the actions of members who may be unscrupulous or mentally incapable of discerning the right from the wrong. The role of law in business and society, as discussed in this paper, is best comprehended with reference to what would ensue if people lived and conducted business in a social setting without any laws. In business, and generally in the society, law serves as the main tool for maintaining orderliness and decency in that it helps in the establishment of a reasonable, fair, and productive environment in accordance to the social cultural perspectives of members in a given society. In business and society in general, law helps to establish a fair ground for all people to compete fairly without exploitation. It is solely with the appropriate laws that all members of the society can venture in business and compete fairly. Reference to a hypothetical situation where business is conducted without any controls over the stock market is an exceptional example to illustrate the role of laws in business and society (Meiners, Ringleb, & Edwards, 2008). In such a scenario, only the privileged would benefit from business and profits from the stock market because only some families and friends would be able to access crucial inside information about the corporations where their associates work. The law, however, strikes the necessary balance ensuring that no specific people or groups are advantaged over others in business under normal circumstances (Sands & Peel, 2012). Such situations may ultimately lead to less lucrative markets where the less privileged just quit because when they are denied opportunities unfairly. The law serves a crucial role in protecting both the interests of business people and consumers within the market setting. Consumers deserve legal protection from exploitative business that may wish to sell substandard products, over charge for goods and services, or sell underweight products. An exceptional example is the Cipollone vs. Liggett Group Incorporation. In this case, the court ruled in favor of Liggett Group, which amounted to the protection of the cigarette manufacturers from exploitation and false allegations by Cipollone. Cipollone had sued the company and other cigarette manufacturers alleging that they violated several consumer protection statuses adopted in New Jersey (Cipollonev. Liggett Group, Inc., 1992). Similarly, business persons require legal protection from consumers who may have bad motives. From the case, it is clear that the law protects both the consumer and the producer from exploiting each other. The law, particularly the public and private law, gives the framework and guidelines that define how the governments and individuals relate. Private law defined the relationships between individuals ensuring that members of the society coexist with minimal conflicts. Importantly, the law is crucial for resolving conflicts that may ensure between individuals or between individuals and the government. Otherwise, without the law, people would not have a legal framework to resolve conflicts and differences. Public law has crucial subdivisions such as the administrative, constitutional, and criminal law used in resolving differences between individuals and governments and the private law helps in resolving individual differences because it governs properties and contracts (Meiners, Ringleb, & Edwards, 2008). Laws are designed to protect and ensure the safety of business interests of individuals and society at large. It does not necessarily matter whether the focus is on individuals, businesses, or societies. The law is designed to ensure fairness in all dealings whether at individual, corporate, or government levels (Meiners, Ringleb, & Edwards, 2008). A careful assessment of the law reveals that societies craft and adopt laws derived from core ethical standards. Therefore, the law is intended to ensure that people deal with each other fairly and with the view that they deal with their own equivalents. In ...
Get the Whole Paper!
Not exactly what you need?
Do you need a custom essay? Order right now:

Other Topics:

Need a Custom Essay Written?
First time 15% Discount!