Summary of Cleary Haley and Sarah Vidal's Article (Essay Sample)

Summary of Cleary Haley and Sarah Vidal’s Article Student’s Name Institutional Affiliation Introduction Based on the Supreme Court decision made in 1966 by the U.S, the amendment by law demands that all suspects in police custody must be given prior advice to avoid self-incrimination due to lack of adequate IQ. The article published by Cleary and Vidal has tried to address the issue of juvenile interrogation by featuring on Miranda rights. Literature Review Notably, the majority of the recent research that incorporates the use of self-report and experimental designs highlights the vulnerability of young people inside the interrogation rooms. These studies focus on the comprehension of the basic constituents of the Miranda warnings as well as the predispositions that waive rights during the unavailability of legal counsel. Moreover, researches on the way the police present the Miranda warnings insinuate that huge variance dominates the locality of jurisdiction since the templates are impracticable. In such a way, dismissing the building blocks of Miranda provides insights of the data concerning the degree of Miranda dominance in live interrogations. Method Essentially, juvenile suspects included 25 men and 3 women. Their age bracket was between 13 to17 years. Firstly, the approach involved the presumed identification of states, the jurisdictions, and departments that recorded data from juvenile interviews put by the state law as a requirement. The research encompassed electronic recording in 13 states. The total number of police departments volunteering into the study was 3,230. On one hand, the mailing of the agencies sent information regarding inter-agency participation. Later on, the data derived from delivery and comprehension of the longitudinal study was coded using Observer XT program. In correspondence, the software program used the transcribed recordings of the police to code the Miranda readability. Lastly, training of coders commenced in accordance with the coding protocol since the reliability of the data involved the employment of matrices to acquire solutions Results In particular, most young people were facing interrogation relating to an individual offense. In this connection, only 11 cases interrogated by police officers involved the administration of Miranda shortly after delaying to ask questions related to booking. Exceptionally, 7% of Miranda cases attracted to police officers who implemented a strategy to dismiss the warnings in a bureaucratic manner. The coding paid attention to the immediate administration of Miranda rights focusing on its delay to foster a built rapport. Finally, only 4% of the cases accused one officer’s attempt to administer Miranda firstly by building rapport with the background of lessening difficulty of juvenile conversation. Discussion The results acquired indicate that the rate at which juveniles waive Miranda rights is high. Notab...