Brief Overview of Critical Appraisal Assignment Article Critique (Article Critique Sample)
Brief overview of Critical Appraisal Assignment
You have to appraise (using appropriate critical appraisal tools) two papers, one qualitative and one quantitative from those provided.
Remember to:
Use APA style of referencing, only the 6th version.
Goal of this assignment: To help you to identify methodological flaws in literature and to make informed decisions about the quality of research evidence.
You need to answer the following three questions:
1. What is the difference between a systematic review and a literature review?
2. What is the purpose of a critical appraisal tool?
3. Of what utility are systematic reviews in healthcare?
These first three question should be no more than 500 words in total
4. Complete a data extraction sheet for one paper (4 articles send separately in pdf)
Yyou decide which one of the four you would like to use.
Further down this page I have provided you with an example of a data extraction sheet, so you can use this style.
5. Complete a critical appraisal tool for one qualitative and one quantitative paper from the four noted above. You decide which two papers to review.
6. Rate and discuss ONE of papers in terms of quality (you decide which one)?
In your opinion (as the researcher), were the tools easy to use?
Did you encounter any difficulties in using the critical appraisal tools?
Watch out for: referencing, spelling, grammar, punctuation and expression.
I have deliberately not set a word limit for sections 4 - 6 of this assignment as the tools that you use may result in variations in how concise you can be.
Please remember that all authors cited in your work (including source of appraisal tools and the papers that you review) must be appropriately referenced using the 6th edition APA format.
Papers for Critical Appraisal Assignment are send separately in pdf.
Please pick one qualitative and one quantitative paper and complete a critical appraisal tool for each.
CASP RCT appraisal tool for completion (send separately in word)
Remember to include explanations for your responses in the checklist, it is not sufficient to just tick the box
e.g.
1 Did the trial address a clearly focused issue? Yes Can't Tell No
X
The authors clearly identified the purpose of the study, which was to ....., they also detailed primary and secondary outcomes. The participants included people with xxx disease, they were volunteers. X was being compared with Y and the following outcomes were measured.....
QUALITATIVE critical appraisal tool for completion (send separately in word)
Remember to include explanations for your responses in the checklist, it is not sufficient to just tick the box.
CASP Critical Appraisal Skills Programme - Qualitative
Paper for appraisal and reference: BIBLIOGRAPHY Pienaar, L., & Reynolds, F. (2015). ‘A respite thing’: A qualitative study of a creative arts leisure programme for family caregivers of people with dementia. Health Psychology Open, 1-11.
-495300428625Section A: Are the results of the trial valid?00Section A: Are the results of the trial valid?
3870325685800HINT: Consider What was the goal of the researchWhy was it thought importantIts relevance00HINT: Consider What was the goal of the researchWhy was it thought importantIts relevance
217170017145YesCan’t tellNo00YesCan’t tellNo1. Was there a clear statement ☒
of the aims of the research? ☐
☐
-495300448310Comments: Yes the statement and the aims of the study have been clearly defined from the study topic and in the introduction which highlights the background of the study and its aims. The aim of the study was to link the security benefits of the presence of loved ones for dementia patients. The this study sought to determine the role played by creative arts support programs for dementia patients. 020000Comments: Yes the statement and the aims of the study have been clearly defined from the study topic and in the introduction which highlights the background of the study and its aims. The aim of the study was to link the security benefits of the presence of loved ones for dementia patients. The this study sought to determine the role played by creative arts support programs for dementia patients.
3841750107315HINT: Consider If the research seeks to interpret or illuminate the actions and / or subjective experiences of research participantsIs qualitative research the right methodology for addressing the research goal00HINT: Consider If the research seeks to interpret or illuminate the actions and / or subjective experiences of research participantsIs qualitative research the right methodology for addressing the research goal
217170017145YesCan’t tellNo00YesCan’t tellNo2. Is a qualitative methodology ☒
appropriate? ☐
☐
-509270448310Comments: qualitative studies are the best when the nature of the study is based on collecting the views, opinions and perception of the participants on the topic CITATION Smi11 \l 1033 (Smith, 2011). From the nature of the study, a qualitative study is appropriate since the nature of the study is to gather the opinions of people on the topic.020000Comments: qualitative studies are the best when the nature of the study is based on collecting the views, opinions and perception of the participants on the topic CITATION Smi11 \l 1033 (Smith, 2011). From the nature of the study, a qualitative study is appropriate since the nature of the study is to gather the opinions of people on the topic.
-5060951621155Is it worth continuing?00Is it worth continuing?
3609975152400HINT: ConsiderIf the researcher has justified the research design (e.g. have they discussed how they decided which method to use)00HINT: ConsiderIf the researcher has justified the research design (e.g. have they discussed how they decided which method to use)217170017145YesCan’t tellNo00YesCan’t tellNo3. Was the research design ☐
appropriate to address the aims ☐
of the research? ☐
-495300448310Comments: yes from the nature of the study topic, interpretive phenomenological analysis is the best qualitative research design for the study since it is a psychological qualitative research method that offers insights on how the participants make sense of a certain phenomenon. Thus this methodology is fit for this study (Smith, 2011). Thus this method allows the easy collection of the feeling of dementia patients on the presence of their loved ones.020000Comments: yes from the nature of the study topic, interpretive phenomenological analysis is the best qualitative research design for the study since it is a psychological qualitative research method that offers insights on how the participants make sense of a certain phenomenon. Thus this methodology is fit for this study (Smith, 2011). Thus this method allows the easy collection of the feeling of dementia patients on the presence of their loved ones.
217170017145YesCan’t tellNo00YesCan’t tellNo4. Was the recruitment strategy ☐
appropriate to the aims of the ☒
research? ☐
Other Topics:
- Critical Thinking Health, Medicine, Nursing Article CritiqueDescription: Kolata (2019) presents a case of two individuals who experience fractures of the fifth metatarsal, in the foot, but take different durations to heal. The first, a Dr. Rosenbaum, after visiting the hospital was told that she had a Jones fracture, which is popularly considered tough to heal...2 pages/≈550 words| 1 Source | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Article Critique |
- Lyme Disease and Peripheral Vascular Disease Medicine Article CritiqueDescription: The signs include the Bull’s eye rash which is seen to be a subset of the Erythema Migran that is also part of the signs. The rash might be seen to appear on other parts of the body apart from the area that was bitten in the form of Disseminated disease. It might be seen as a red mark...1 page/≈275 words| 1 Source | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Article Critique |
- Critical Review on Nursing Leadership Medicine Article CritiqueDescription: The article concerns the influence of nursing leadership in championing cost reduction, efficiency, and performance in the health care sector. This research sought the views of technology users concerning the impact of leadership in promoting the adoption of innovations. Researchers study sampled...3 pages/≈825 words| 3 Sources | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Article Critique |
