Philosophical dialogue (Essay Sample)
Socrates and Protagoras are having an argumentative dialogue on virtue and unity. The aim of the dialogue in relation to the arguments of the two philosophers is to formulate a platform of exploring issues beyond their consideration. The dialogue will consider the position of Socrates on the unity of particular virtues with virtue itself.source..
Virtue and Unity
Socrates and Protagoras are having an argumentative dialogue on virtue and unity. The aim of the dialogue in relation to the arguments of the two philosophers is to formulate a platform of exploring issues beyond their consideration. The dialogue will consider the position of Socrates on the unity of particular virtues with virtue itself.
Protagoras: Can virtue be taught?
Socrates: My brother, virtue cannot be taught.
* Socrates states that virtue cannot be taught while Protagoras maintains that virtue is teachable.
Protagoras: I am a teacher of virtue
Socrates: I am not a teacher of virtue
* The dialogue indicates that Protagoras is a teacher of virtue while Socrates cannot teach virtue. Phenomenology of morality affirms that virtue cannot be taught by appealing to democratic practices. It is better to appeal to phenomenology to get a certain interpretation. On his side, Socrates is not doubtful there are virtuous people. He thinks that people pick up virtue on their own. He critically rejects the view that virtue can be taught.
Socrates: Virtue is not teachable because of the following:
* We listen to all in matters of policies as there are no experts that have knowledge and in matters where things are taught, we listen to experts and what they say goes
* Good people don't necessarily have good children as they can teach them some things but can't teach them sound judgment
* Good people send their children off to experts to teach them sound judgment but they fail just as the good people failed (Plato 6).
Protagoras: Let me respond to your argument that virtue cannot be taught by adducing to the
* Story of the creation of society and the role of the gods in it
* Without sound judgment we can't be a defined species
* Hermes gives us the skill of association and the art of politics - can't band together and defend ourselves without this but we could survive
* Shame guides us to act well and justice enables us to act well
* Art of politics, sense of shame and justice, is given to all unlike craft
Protagoras: Teaching virtue is the initial development of a talent within us.
Even though Protagoras has a theory to support the claim that virtue can be taught, he does not provide conclusive evidence to support the assertion. He does not prove that virtue is taught. Protagoras fails to convince Socrates that virtue is teachable because he does not provide appropriate proof.
Socrates: I am appealing to the practices of ethics
* Callicles could have stated that he prefers an argument on the nature of virtue to the conventions of virtue.
On the nature of virtue;
Protagoras: Punishment is a form of taking vengeance
* Protagoras still insists that virtue is teachable, contrary to the arguments of So...
- Film "Why We Fight" EssayDescription: In the film Why we fight, Eugene Jarecki explores explanations as to why American young men and women are sent to war...4 pages/≈1100 words| 3 Sources | MLA | Social Sciences | Essay |
- Social Deviance Research: Gender And Delinquency Description: Gender and delinquency have been studied for quite some time now and there seems to be an association between the two....4 pages/≈1100 words| 6 Sources | MLA | Social Sciences | Essay |
- Human rightsDescription: Human rights Social Sciences Essay...10 pages/≈2750 words| MLA | Social Sciences | Essay |