Sign In
Not register? Register Now!
6 pages/≈1650 words
6 Sources
Health, Medicine, Nursing
Article Critique
English (U.S.)
MS Word
Total cost:
$ 31.32

Measurement of Body Temperature (Article Critique Sample)


the instructions required the writer to select six research articles from the body of literature concerning the accuracy of Temporal versus rectal temperature. the essay content included the weaknesses and strengths of the articles in relation to design, sampling, data collection, statistical analysis, results, and discussion of the study and an explanation of proposed changes recommended to improve the quality of the study, capitalizing on the strengths and improving on the weaknesses identified in the study.


Article Critique
Article Critique
Body temperature is among the four significant vital signs that should be monitored to ensure effective and safe care. However, healthcare facilities face challenges in establishing the medical importance of the measured temperature and lack reliable methods and tools for determining body core temperature. While different methods and techniques are utilized to determine body temperature, it is crucial to use the most appropriate method to guarantee accuracy. Inaccurate readings may fail to establish patient deterioration and impact diagnosis and treatment, leading to compromised patient safety. Although the rectal temperature is the most precise technique for determining core temperature, it is often more time-consuming and unfavorable for some patients than the temporal artery temperature method.
Forehead or Ear Temperature Measurement Cannot Replace Rectal Measurements, Except for Screening Purposes.
In their article, Mogensen et al. (2018) conducted a cross-sectional study to compare rectal temperatures to tympanic and temporal temperatures in 0-18-year-old-children. They aimed to assess whether the ear or forehead temperature measurements could be utilized in screening to diagnose fever and if the conformity with the rectal temperature for diverse age groups is suitable for medical use. Their findings indicated that the rectal thermometer had a considerably greater capability to detect fever than the temporal and tympanic thermometers (Mogensen et al., 2018). However, the technique was traumatic compared to the other temperature measurement methods.
The study is an inclusive factual, pragmatic survey with sub-analyses in diverse age groups, augmenting its generalizability and applicability. Additionally, contrary to numerous published studies, it was evaluated using suitable techniques, including the Bland-Altman analysis. The technique was valuable in assessing the repeatability of values and determining the mean difference of the temperatures and the association between the degree of the compared analysis. However, the survey was conducted anonymously, making the comparison between non-participating and participating children to assess selection bias impossible. Additionally, the sequence of temperature measurements was similar throughout the research, which might have resulted in a bias.
The researchers should conduct the survey openly to enable comparison between the participating and non-participating children to determine the presence or absence of selection bias. They should also ensure varying temperature measurement sequences to eliminate possible selection bias. The study provides recommendations for accurate temperature measurements within health facilities. It suggests that clinicians should use rectal temperatures since the other techniques are less convincing as they have an agreement range of about ±1°C that is too wide for medical use.
Comparison Between Temporal and Rectal Temperature Measurement
In their publication, Nygaard, Maschmann, and Ekmann (2020) conducted a prospective, comparative study to compare the precision of conventional rectal thermometer (REC) and temporal artery thermometer (TAT) in adults above 18 years admitted in the emergency department. The variations between the REC and TAT ranged from -1.7°C to +1.7 °C. The standard deviation of the variances was ±0.47 signifying a broader disparity of measures than the initial acceptable

Get the Whole Paper!
Not exactly what you need?
Do you need a custom essay? Order right now:

Other Topics:

  • Hospitals and Health Systems Prepare for a Value-Driven Future
    Description: Hospitals seek to improve community health outcomes by controlling costs. However, accomplishing these goals requires hospitals to actively collaborate with payers to create effective value-based payment (VBP) models. Federal and state policies can drive alignment across public and private VBP efforts to...
    2 pages/≈550 words| 1 Source | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Article Critique |
  • Causes of Anxiety Disorder
    Description: Anxiety disorder is a mental health condition exhibited by worry or fear that can interfere with a person's daily activities. It is also a group of related conditions, each with unique symptoms, but all have the same characteristic of persistence and excessive fear. There are various types of anxiety ...
    1 page/≈275 words| 2 Sources | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Article Critique |
  • The 1918 Flu, Masks and Lessons for the Coronavirus Pandemic
    Description: The 1918 Flu presented a significant health issue that affected various cities in the United States. In particular, many lives were lost as the disease spread among thousands of Americans, as evidenced in the article. Different terms referred to the masks, including muzzles, dirt traps, and germ shields....
    2 pages/≈550 words| 1 Source | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Article Critique |
Need a Custom Essay Written?
First time 15% Discount!