Battling over Bottled Water (Coursework Sample)

Battling over Bottled Water Name Institution Date Battling Over Bottled Water Q1. Whether Michigan people should be concerned with how the groundwater is used Yes. It is within their rights to know about who and how the State's groundwater is used. If this is not put into consideration, then Companies and people are likely to excessively use water, and in return, this will lead to water shortage. Water shortage is catastrophic, not only to the humans and animals but also to the general environment. Virtually, any living thing needs water for the entire survival. If the amount of groundwater recedes below the expected level, the likely hood is that the water table will get lowered further hence threatening the existence of the fauna and flora on the earth. For instance, plants, wildlife, and humans will lack this important resource; hence death is likely to occur. This means that without good environmental concerns, the living environment is likely to become inhabitable or unsuitable for living. Even though the Companies are doing a greater job in the creation of employment opportunities, the impacts are likely to be more dangerous than thought before. With little regulations being put across to protect water, the companies are using this opportunity to benefit themselves rather than the common people, hence the need for such concerns. Q2. “Reasonable use” if Nestle pumps more than 262 million gallons from sanctuary spring, and whether this is an unfair treatment to the Natives and the residents The Nestlé’s pumping of more than 262 gallons of water from the sanctuary constitutes to “unreasonable use” Despite the fact that the doctrine states “the owners of a stream can use water for drinking, boating, swimming, or anything else “as long as it is in connection with their land”, it does not talk about transportation of water to other places for the sake of gaining profits. The amount of water being used in this case (262 million gallons) is unreasonable from all points of view. However, personally, I perceive that the Company is treating the locals fairly, especially in relation to job creation and economic boost. Concerning the Native American tribes, the whole deal is unfair because they are not considered. Therefore, it will be fair to restrict this Company from using the spring’s water simply because they have done very little in meeting the moral aspect of their action. Their main focus is driven by greed and profit ideologies. 3. Whether groundwater is a public or private resource and those with the strongest claim. Just like nature and the natural environment, groundwater is a public resource. This means that all citizens have the right to equal access to the resource, and therefore, its regulation is in the hands of the society. At the larger extent, the society has knowledge of the amount of water which satisfies the entire population. If the owners of the land tend to regulate water, then this will be unethical and unfair because they will be operating with bias and inequality. Additionally, if they (owners of the land) are provided with the opportunity to make decisions, it...