Conscientious Objection and Professional Responsibility (Essay Sample)

Case Study: Conscientious Objection and Professional Responsibility Student’s Name Student Number Course Name Course Number Submission Date Summary of Facts The aforementioned case study centres around Nurse Amelia Brooks, an employee of Riverside Medical Centre. She is struggling with existential ethics. Due to extreme opposition to abortion, Amelia was initially expected to help 24-year-old Sophie Turner, an alumni understudy, with elective fetal removal in the junction. She is thus forced to choose between her personal traits and her professional obligations. These abilities consider the patient's needs and concerns in addition to caring for them in a non-oppressive manner. Amelia's situation demonstrates rather clearly how often health professionals must walk the delicate balance between personal morality and patient care. This narrative can be used to demonstrate how most ethical problems in medicine are divisive since professional demands and personal ideals don't always coincide, calling for an alternative course of action. Ethical Decision-Making Model Analysis In order to comprehend the components of moral navigation—Soul, moral reasoning, and morals—we can apply tidbits of knowledge from the examination articles by McKenna and Jeske and Molina-Mula and Gallo-Estrada to the contextual analysis involving medical attendant Amelia Streams and her ethical dilemma regarding cooperation in an early termination strategy. Moral Awareness: In all honesty, the Amelia case illustrates an ethical dilemma involving personal judgment regarding the termination of an embryo and word-related obligations. McKenna and Jeske observed that moral administration is crucial in the health services industry because it requires personnel to adhere to ethical standards. The case of Amelia at Riverside Clinical Center serves as an illustrative example of how administration might respond to morally complex situations by presenting viable options grounded in professional ethics and private standards.[McKenna, Jayne, and Debora Jeske. "Ethical leadership and decision authority effects on nurses’ engagement, exhaustion, and turnover intention." Journal of Advanced Nursing 77, no. 1 (2021): 198-206.] Moral Judgment: Amelia’s moral judgment is influenced by various factors. It is not hard to see that the core beliefs and values which are based on religious doctrines clearly contradict her active involvement in the abortion process. Instead, the code of ethics can be used which defines detachment care and highlights patient’s interests and autonomy. Molina-Mula and Gallo-Estrada focused on the nurse patient relationship and patients’ autonomy in decision making. This element is especially significant in Amelia’s assessment. However, the independence of Sophie Turner and her body problems should be considered as she is in that state.[Molina-Mula, Jesús, and Julia Gallo-Estrada. "Impact of nurse-patient relationship on quality of care and patient autonomy in decision-making." International journal of environmental research and public health 17, no. 3 (2020): 835.] Application of Academic Articles The framework for the ethical dilemma analysis of Amelia in health care is based on essential principles provided by McKenna and Jeske and Molina-Mula and Gallo-Estrada. These studies are the foundation of personal beliefs, ethics and nurse-patient relationship in decision making.[McKenna, Jayne, and Debora Jeske. "Ethical leadership and decision authority effects on nurses’ engagement, exhaustion, and turnover intention." Journal of Advanced Nursing 77, no. 1 (2021): 198-206.Molina-Mula, Jesús, and Julia Gallo-Estrada. "Impact of nurse-patient relationship on quality of care and patient autonomy in decision-making." International journal of environmental research and public health 17, no. 3 (2020): 835.] McKenna and Jeske study the effect of ethical leadership and decision-making authority on nurses’ engagement, fatigue, and turnover intention. This study implies that ethical leadership leads nurses to issues like Amelia’s paradox. As the authors note, leadership in health care empowers nurses to make decisions based on their ethics and work requirements. The ethical leadership by Riverside Medical Center can be a source of comfort and understanding for Amelia during her moral dilemma that would help to decrease work-related stress and turnover intentions.[McKenna, Jayne, and Debora Jeske. "Ethical leadership and decision authority effects on nurses’ engagement, exhaustion, and turnover intention." Journal of Advanced Nursing 77, no. 1 (2021): 198-206.] Molina-Mula and Gallo-Estrada emphasise the importance of the caregiver-patient relationship and the autonomy of patients as caretakers in the context of dynamic health processes. Persistent independence can be interpreted as Sophie Turner's overall right to early termination in her work on the nature of care. In the realm of patient autonomy and steadfast complaint, Amelia's case unequivocally concerns this principle.[Molina-Mula, Jesús, and Julia Gallo-Estrada. "Impact of nurse-patient relationship on quality of care and patient autonomy in decision-making." International journal of environmental research and public health 17, no. 3 (2020): 835.] Communication Approaches in Ethical Dilemmas Effectiveness According to Afriyie, the essential components of effective therapeutic communication are expressing thoughts, empathy, and consideration. If Amelia follows these criteria, her conversation with Dr. Martin regarding his sources of extreme distress will be brief and concise. Amelia's straightforwardness exhibits her awareness, and her temperament could contribute to the development of a more constructive approach in resolving conflicts. In reality, the lack of communication over certain topics, such as important debates or feelings of jealousy, would have resulted in misunderstandings, conflicts, and social isolation.[Afriyie, Dorothy. "Effective communication between nurses and patients: an evolutionary concept analysis." British Journal of Community Nursing 25, no. 9 (2020): 438-445.] Recommended Approaches Afriyie's findings indicate that open communication, defined as a necessity, may need to be mandatory. Amelia should engage in a two-way conversation where both her position and that of Dr. Martin are talked about with regard. Empathy allows Amelia to understand the needs of a patient and the professional aspect of this situation, while assertiveness ensures that her beliefs and values are communicated as well. The active or assertive communication style reduces the chances of conflict and misinterpretation.[Afriyie, Dorothy. "Effective communication between nurses and patients: an evolutionary concept analysis." British Journal of Community Nursing 25, no. 9 (2020): 438-445.] Consequences In this situation, the appropriate communication can lead to many benefits. It can result in a compromise between Amelia’s moral concerns and the demands of the patient. This can also include recruiting another nurse to assist in the surgery. On the other hand, poor communication may not just affect Amelia’s business relationships but also her level of efficiency at work and mental state. Furthermore, inadequate communication may also impact on patient care if it leads to an uncomfortable setting. Approach to Ethical Practice Problems When addressing her ethical dilemma, it is Amelia’s response and actions that are important. If she follows the recommendations contained in the literature, Amelia would likely address her issues to Dr. Rebecca Martin and appropriate hospital management highlighting moral dilemma while discussing professional duties. This aspect would be key in the establishment of open and compassionate communication leading an atmosphere for a just settlement.[Afriyie, Dorothy. "Effective communication between nurses and patients: an evolutionary concept analysis." British Journal of Community Nursing 25, no. 9 (2020): 438-445.] Amelia’s approach to reconciliation should be the compromise between personal morals and patient care. Ethical leadership by Amelia in her organisation or other options, including delegating this task to other nurses who would be ready to accept responsibility for patient care while preserving patient autonomy.[Molina-Mula, Jesús, and Julia Gallo-Estrada. "Impact of nurse-patient relationship on quality of care and patient autonomy in decision-making." International journal of environmental research and public health 17, no. 3 (2020): 835.] The Proposed ...